Pedagogical expertise of teacher activity in Russia: problems of formation and institutional development (1920–2020s)
https://doi.org/10.51955/2312-1327_2025_4_184
Abstract
The article presents a comprehensive analysis of the formation and institutional development of pedagogical expertise in Russia (1920-2020s) as a key mechanism for assessing and regulating teachers' professional competencies. The specific features of the formation of domestic expert practices are revealed; their interrelation with the socio-political and technological transformations of Russian society is substantiated; the cyclical nature of the problems of the institute of expertise in education (ideologization, formalization, crisis, standardization) is determined. The various innovative approaches for its improvement are being considered. The potential for the development of tools for measuring the effectiveness of pedagogical practice is shown through a multimodal system for evaluating pedagogical effectiveness; a digital ecosystem of expert communities; personalized professional growth trackers, etc. The materials of the article can be useful in developing new criteria for evaluating teachers, taking into account not only formal indicators (length of service, qualifications), but also pedagogical effectiveness, innovative methods.; to create algorithms to reduce the bureaucratic workload during evaluations; to develop educational programs for experts, including courses in pedagogical analytics, as well as to prevent systemic crises and predict risks. The conclusions of the study emphasize the uniqueness of the Russian experience of pedagogical expertise and the need to develop local solutions that take into account the specifics of the national education system.
About the Author
D. V. Fedotov
Irkutsk State University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Dmitry. V. Fedotov
1, Karl Marx St., Irkutsk, 664003
References
1. Belyaev M. F. (1925). On the problem of pedagogical expertise. Irkutsk: Publishing House, 1925. 20. (in Russian)
2. Bessalova V. S. (2023). The theoretical aspect of pedagogical expertise and its application in the educational process. Scientific aspect. 9(7): pp.1116-1122. (in Russian)
3. Bibikova V. V. (2013). Professional and class inspections of teachers in the first half of the 1920s in Yenisei Siberia. Yaroslavl Pedagogical Bulletin. 2(1): pp.85-91. (in Russian)
4. Bychkov A. V. (2021). The standard of scientific pedagogical expertise: the creative. Standards and monitoring in education. 9(5). Pp.32-38. (in Russian)
5. Cherepanov V. S. (1990). Theoretical foundations of pedagogical expertise. 1990. 351 p. (in Russian)
6. Demakova I. D., Popova I. I. (2021). Humanitarian expertise as a method of scientific cognition in pedagogy. Bulletin of the Moscow State Pedagogical University. (60). Pp.37-48. (in Russian)
7. Digital transformation in education: problems and development prospects: collection of materials of the Interregional scientific and practical conference / ed. by M. A. Selivanova. Lipetsk: GOUDPO LO "IRO", 2021. 164. (in Russian)
8. Erokhina E. P. (2016). The work of a teacher is difficult and honorable: the level of workload and remuneration of a Soviet teacher in the 1930s (based on materials from Mordovia). Bulletin of the Nizhny Novgorod University named after N. I. N. Lobachevsky. (5). Pp.18-22. (in Russian)
9. Erokhina E. P. (2017). How teachers of the 30s of the last century lived and worked. Available at: https://pedsovet.org/article/kak-zilos-i-rabotalos-ucitelam-30-h-proslogo-stoletia (accessed 20 June 2025). (in Russian)
10. Ewing E. T. (2011). Teachers of the Stalinist Era: Power, Politics, and School Life in the 1930s. Moscow: ROSSPEN, 2011. 359 p. (in Russian)
11. Fedotov D. V. (2023). The formation and development of the phenomenon of pedagogical expertise in the Russian education of the XX - early XXI century. Standards and monitoring in education. 11 (2). 52-55. (in Russian)
12. For the first time, cross-university expertise is being launched in Russia. (2025). Available at: https://m.minobrnauki.gov.ru/press-center/news/nauka-i-obrazovanie/97862/ (accessed 08 July 2025). (in Russian)
13. Gavrilina M. A., Kulikova L. V. (2021). Innovative educational practice as an object of pedagogical expertise. Bulletin of scientific conferences. (74). Pp.13-15. (in Russian)
14. Gorbachev V. V. (2022). Pedagogical expertise according to the current Russian legislation: essence, problems, effectiveness. Legal technology. (16). Pp.268-271. (in Russian)
15. Gorbunova N. V. (2020). Pedagogical expertise as an empirical method of implementing psychological and pedagogical research. Problems of modern pedagogical education. 66-1: 59- 61. (in Russian)
16. Gornostaeva N. V. (2016). The history of the formation of pedagogical diagnostics in Russia. Young Scientist. (124). Pp.675-678. (in Russian)
17. How the Bolsheviks radically reformed the school, and then got tired of experimenting (2022). Available at: https://skillbox.ru/media/education/kak-bolsheviki-radikalno-reformirovali-shkolua-potom-ustali-ot-eksperimentov/ (accessed 17 June 2025). (in Russian)
18. Kiseleva E. V. (2020). Pedagogical expertise of the educational process in an educational organization. 2020. 270 p. (in Russian)
19. Kolokolnikova Z. U., Mosintsev D. D., Blintsova I. M. (2022). Comparative analysis of the rights and duties of a teacher: the 20s of the XX and XXI centuries. Problems of modern pedagogical education. 74-4: 109-112. (in Russian)
20. Novikov S. G. (2012). Development of the «New Man» model by the Soviet power elite of the 1920s. Izvestiya VGPU. 5(69). Pp.154-158. (in Russian)
21. On the strategic directions of education development in the Russian Federation in the context of modern challenges. (2025). Available at: http://council.gov.ru/activity/documents/165012/. (accessed 16 May 2025). (in Russian)
22. Ovchinnikov A. V. (2020). Power and teaching in Russia during the Great Patriotic War. Domestic and foreign pedagogy. (66). Pp.7-17. (in Russian)
23. Podlinyaev O. L., Fedotov D. V. (2022). Promotion of professional and personal growth of teachers by means of pedagogical expertise: a retrospective analysis of the problem. Development of education. 5(1). Pp.25-29. (in Russian)
24. Rudenko E. Yu. (2022). The problems of educational reforms in the USSR in the 1950s and 80s. Young scientist. (401). Pp.55-57. (in Russian)
25. Savvinov V. M. (2024). Assessment of education transformation management. Izvestiya RSPU named after A. N. I. N. Herzen. (212). Pp.9-19. (in Russian)
26. Shcheglov I. A. (2023). Issues of algorithmization of the production of humanitarian expertise. Humanitarian Bulletin. 5 (103). (in Russian)
27. Veretennikova V. B., Shikhova O. F., Shikhov Yu. A. (2020). Pedagogical expertise of the structure and content of professional competencies of future teachers of the preschool education system. Education and self-development. 15 (4). Pp.80-98. (in Russian)
28. What do teachers think about certification? (2020). Available at: https://m.ok.ru/group/57147355562081/album/887229576545/889851636321 (accessed 14 June 2025). (in Russian)
29. What should be the teacher's assessment (2021). Available at: https://dzen.ru/a/YUrTQyJZeB39hUTv (accessed 10 June 2025). (in Russian)
30. Yakovlev S. V. (2021). Scientific contribution of K. N. N. Kornilov, I. N. F. N. Svadkovsky to the development of the content of psychological and pedagogical training of future teachers in the early−mid-20th century. Journal of Pedagogical Research. 6(5). Pp.87-93. (in Russian)
Review
For citations:
Fedotov D.V. Pedagogical expertise of teacher activity in Russia: problems of formation and institutional development (1920–2020s). Crede Experto: transport, society, education, language. 2025;(4):184-199. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.51955/2312-1327_2025_4_184
Views:
26
JATS XML
Email this article 